Forbidden Read online

It was a whole three weeks later, making it a solid month when Maddy busted into my room after I'd led my team to a thirty five to three victory over our biggest rival.

  "Guess what?"

  She was like a little ball of energy hopping from foot to foot with excitement.

  "What?" I had just dropped my bag on the floor next to the bed and was about to pull my shirt over my head.

  "She's going to do it."

  My heart fucking stopped, of course I knew who she was talking about but I couldn't seem too eager, couldn't give myself away.

  "Who's going to do what?" I played the nonchalant role to the hilt.

  "Isabella silly, can you believe it?"

  I felt my dick begin to thicken already, shit if Madelyn, noticed that might put the brakes on this little expedition before it got off the ground.

  "When?" Was that my voice, I sounded like a drowning frog.

  "Now, your parents are gone to dinner and you know what that means, they'll be out all night. It's Friday besides, no school tomorrow."

  She clapped her hands together like a kid in a candy store.

  Well where was she?

  Chapter 5

  The door opened slightly and then a very shy, very timid Isabella came into my room.

  She was wearing a very UnBella like sweater dress in cream that stopped about three inches above her knees, with knee high three inch heeled brown boots, with a sexy as fuck buckle around the ankles. Why I found that piece of metal so fucking enticing I'll never know.

  The dress fit like a second skin and the V necked showed off the tops of her tits. My mouth fucking watered, I have no idea how we were supposed to play out this Greek farce, but I know for damn sure somebody needed to get this show on the road before I combusted.

  Since the whole thing was Maddy's idea I decided to let her take the lead...for now.

  She drew Isabella deeper into the room to stand before me; I can't believe that this is actually happening, that I'm about to taste her.

  After years of loving her one way, I now saw her in this whole new light, as someone desirable, someone I wanted to devour.

  She kept her head down as Madelyn placed her hands on her shoulders.

  "Come on Bella, remember what we talked about?"

  Wait a minute, did she somehow coerce her into this, as much as I wanted her the thought of fucking her against her will was like a bucket of ice-cold water on my libido.

  "Isabella, look at me...."

  She finally raised her head to look at me, the blush covered her whole body, or at least what I could see of it down to her cleavage.

  "You do not have to do this if you're not comfortable."

  "Drake..."

  I gave Madelyn a harsh look that shut her up, I know she thinks she's running the show but this was Isabella's first time, I wasn't about to use her just so Maddy could live out her kinky fantasy.

  If she didn't want this I would respect that, it might kill me to walk away after reaching this far, but for her I would do it.

  "No...Drake...it's okay, I want to, I just don't know what to do."

  Her softly spoken words were like balm to my soul, my erection thumped even harder.

  We'd discussed this for the last few weeks Maddy and I and I'm sure these two had as well.

  Since it was her first time and she was inherently shy to begin with, we thought it best if Maddy showed her how I liked to be touched.

  Maddy took the initiative and started pulling on the waistband of my sweats, my erection sprang free, bounced and settled in its' usual salute to my navel, pre cum already coating the head and shaft in copious amounts.

  "Come on Bella, just like I showed you on the cucumber remember?"

  She took the head of my cock in her mouth, her tongue dipping into my slit; I had briefly closed my eyes until I remembered we had an audience.

  Flashing my eyes open, I saw Isabella with her eyes locked on Maddy's mouth as it wrapped around my girth, I held still not daring to move less I cum too soon.

  Maddy pulled off with a pop, my phallus held tightly in her fist.

  "You try." She held my erection out to my little stepsister who dropped to her knees, her eyes transfixed on my growth.

  Eyes closed, her tongue came out to lick my tip, where pre cum was once again drooling unchecked.

  When her lips closed around the head of my cock I thought I might explode, nothing prepared me for the emotion that rioted through me, the love and lust that took control.

  The look of utter delight that crossed her face held me mesmerized as her soft hand came up to hold my shaft as she took me deeper into her mouth.

  Seeing that Isabella was handling her first blowjob, Maddy kissed her way up my chest, nipping at my nipples before catching my mouth in a kiss.

  The feelings were indescribable, having my dick sucked while tonguing another woman's mouth was like nothing I'd ever experienced before.

  I thrust my hips gently back and forth, as Isabella took more and more of me, careful not to thrust too hard or too far.

  "Stop." I pulled my mouth and my dick away, I was about to cum, the sensations were too much for me.

  I looked down into Isabella's eyes and something passed between us, something that made my heart thump within my chest.

  I'd almost forgotten Maddy was there until she pulled me towards the bed.

  The two of them got undressed before joining me, one on each side, as they laid next to me, I turned to Isabella, looking into her eyes I saw heat, need, and want before I lowered my head and took her soft mouth with mine.

  It was our first real kiss and when I felt her little tongue come out to play with mine I was a goner.

  I turned more fully towards her, pulling her body flush with mine, she felt so small next to me, her five foot two body dwarfed by my six three frame, the sensations caused by this were insurmountable.

  Maddy had wanted me to take Isabella from behind, she didn't really want any true intimacy to pass between us, in my rush to agree to anything just to feel Isabella, I had agreed, but now I knew this wasn't going to be possible.

  There was no way I could do that to her.

  I felt Maddy's hand that she'd been running up and down my back to my ass tense as I rolled over between Isabella's legs. It wouldn't have mattered if she screamed bloody murder, it wouldn't have altered my course.

  I barely spared a glance for her not too pleased expression, I wanted to just plunge into the body beneath me, but what little control I had left begged me to do this right, make it as memorable and as enjoyable as possible.

  I wasn't sure if she would have an orgasm her first time so I sought to bring her off another way first.

  Her pudendum was plump, pale pink, lovely.

  I lowered my nose and inhaled her bouquet, fresh, sweet, woman. I licked her once, she jerked. Her cleft was moist with her arousal as I flattened my tongue and licked from her opening to her clit.

  My dick was hard and aching as I rubbed it against the bed to ease the strain.

  Lifting her ass in both hands, I sucked harder before pushing my tongue partway into her.

  Her hands found purchase in my hair as she undulated beneath my mouth.

  She grunted as I ate her pussy, her small ass in my hands bringing me to the brink of madness. It didn't help that Maddy was now fondling my balls from behind as she bit and sucked the skin my ass.

  I lifted up a little and her hand slipped under me to stroke my erection as I continued to tongue fuck Isabella.

  Rising up on my knees, I splayed her legs over my thighs opening her up to my gaze. Her silky labia were closed as if guarding her precious jewel from my marauding cock. I felt her with my fingertips, her readiness obvious.

  Running my hand over my hardness, I collected some pre cum, rubbing it into her pussy along with her juices, making her slippery and hopefully wet enough to take me.

  Pushing forward, I touched the top of my cock to her entrance, careful not to push too far too quickly.<
br />
  I looked into her eyes; she was concentrating, biting her lip.

  I mouthed the words that were in my heart not daring to say them out loud because I know, I know that if I uttered them now Maddy would know, she would know that my profession of love was not the love of a brother for his sister, but the love a man felt for his woman.

  Chapter 6

  I blocked everything else out, Maddy was no longer here, it was just my sweet Isabella, the girl of my heart, the one who had always owned it and me.

  I pushed my crown into her, her sweet sex dilated with each inch I put into her, when I felt her virginity give way, saw the ring of blood appear around my shaft, I held still.

  "You okay baby?" It was a whisper meant for her ears only.

  It might be unfair, but all my focus was on her right now, even as Maddy bit from my neck down to my spine, her hands moving all over me.

  All my concentration, all my emotions, were invested solely on Isabella. I lifted her legs higher up around my waist as she nodded.

  Laying my chest down on hers, my hands holding her ass, I fucked into her with soft, slow strokes at first.

  She clutched me so tightly I almost couldn't move, pressing my thumb into her clit, I slid deeper inside and she clenched and released, her body producing more of her juices, easing my way into her.

  The bed squeaked as I picked up the pace, I bent to kiss her lips but was interrupted by Maddy pulling my face towards her, pushing her tongue into my mouth as Isabella's hands ran over my ass, pulling me deeper into her. Fuck.

  I pulled my mouth away from Maddy and as I kissed Isabella's lips ravenously, my dick finally pounding out of control, Maddy whispered in my ear.

  "Don't cum in her, I'll be so mad..."

  Fuck you, that's what I wanted to scream at her, she'd done this, opened this door, now she could deal with it because I had no intention of stopping.

  I felt the tingles that heralded the onslaught of my orgasm, leaving her mouth, I took her nipple between my teeth and licked and bit. She squeezed around me, legs stiffening, little grunts escaping her lips as she fought for her own release.

  I took a chance and used some of our escaped juices to moisten her rosebud before pushing my finger in to the first knuckle.

  She bucked against me and came with one long drawn out groan as I spilled my seed inside her.

  I barely registered Maddy's fist pounding into my back I didn't care.

  I pulled Isabella into my chest as I rolled to my side cuddling her close.

  I've been fucking for a while now, knew way more about sex than I should have for even longer than that, and I have never ever experienced anything like this in my life.

  I had the presence of mind to roll back into the middle and pull Maddy into my other side.

  She resisted at first but when I kissed her brow she relented, but slightly. I knew there was going to be trouble, what I'd just experienced, there's no way I could let that go.

  It opened my eyes to so many things, like my refusal to accept early graduation when it would've meant jumpstarting my life, why I was so adamant that Isabella join me at school.

  All this time I thought I was looking out for her like a brother with his younger sister but no, that wasn't it.

  I'm in love with this girl. Fuck me.

  In my stupor I got up from the bed and went to my en suite to run a bath for her, I was going make sure she had the best experience out of this whole thing, no half stepping.

  Maddy will just have to get over whatever the hell her problem was, but if she expected me to short change Isabella just to make her feel better she could kill that noise.

  When I got back to the room there was a lot of hushed voices and gesticulating. I was just in time to hear Maddy proclaim Isabella a slut.

  "What the fuck, have you lost your mind?"

  She jumped off the bed to confront me, I could see anger and hurt in her eyes, looking over to Isabella I saw her curled into a ball rocking back-and-forth. As a kid she always did that shit when she was distressed, I wanted so much to go to her but knew that would only make the situation worse.

  "What did you do Maddy?"

  "What did I do? What did I do? You were only supposed to fuck her Drake not fucking make love to the little bitch. I'm your girlfriend and you've never touched me like that."

  Her chest was heaving with her anger, how the fuck was I supposed to diffuse this situation, how could I when everything she said was true?

  In her scenario I wasn't even supposed to finish in Isabella, I was supposed to fuck her, take her virginity, maybe give her an orgasm and then turn to Maddy my girlfriend; it was all part of her fantasy.

  Now that I thought about it that was some cold shit, I was so blinded by lust for the past month that I never stopped to think about what the fuck was going on, her sudden interest in a ménage, her insistence that it had to be Isabella, her breaking Isabella down until she agreed.

  Fuck, what had I done? She'd resented Isabella in the beginning, hated our closeness, I stupidly believed that all the time she spent with Isabella since then had been out of friendship, now I wasn't so sure.

  Was this some sort of setup? Had she played me, played us both but why? I couldn't put it together right now and I needed to handle the situation so I could take care of my little Isabella.

  "Come on Isabella I ran you a bath." I moved around Maddy to the bed and picked her up. I heard Maddy gasp behind me and turned to face her.

  "Wait here I'll be right back."

  She folded her arms and gave me a death glare.

  I whispered sweet nothings to Isabella as I lowered her into the warm water.

  "It's going to be okay Isabella please don't cry, I'll take care of everything."

  "You hate me now."

  "What.... no, why would you say that?"

  She did that rocking thing again as tears rolled down her cheeks.

  "Listen, let me go talk with Maddy, I'll be right back to check on you in a little bit. I don't hate you, I could never hate you, never." I kissed her hair before standing and leaving the room.

  Maddy was still fuming when I returned.

  "That was way out of line Maddy, remember this was your idea, not hers, not mine, why would you turn around and call her a slut for doing exactly what you, her friend talked us both into doing?"

  "Yeah well it didn't look like you needed much convincing, you sure seemed to be having a great fucking time."

  "What did you expect, did you expect me to rape her or some shit, would it have made you feel better if I'd roughed her up?"

  "No, of course not don't be stupid."

  "Well?"

  "I just didn't expect you to enjoy it so much, I didn't expect to feel the way I did, for a moment there it seemed like you two were alone, like I didn't even exist for you."

  I felt guilt prick my conscience because she was so right. While inside Isabella everything and everyone else ceased to exist.

  I pulled her into my arms to offer comfort and even then I was wishing I could be back in the bathroom with Isabella taking care of her.

  I understood a little of what she was feeling, we maybe should've thought this through a bit more.

  "You need to calm down Maddy, I think it's just all new to both of us, all of us in fact, you can't attack her like that again, I know you really don't want to hear this right now, but I'm going to say it anyway, you will never talk to her like that again, no one talks to her like that, especially not in my presence, don't you ever do that again."

  "You see that's what I'm talking about." She pulled out of my arms, her voice raised in anger.

  "Ssh, keep your voice down, like I said, you don't want to hear it right now but I've been looking out for her for nine years I'm not about to stop now, she doesn't deserve to be treated like trash just because you can't handle a situation of your own making. You want to act like an injured party, go right ahead, but you take that shit out on me not her."

  She stormed
around the room collecting her clothes.

  "I always knew you wanted to fuck her."

  "What are you talking about, I never thought of that until you brought it up, now stop being a jerk and calm the fuck down. How do you think she's going to feel with you acting like this?"

  "See what I mean, all you think about is her, it's always her Isabella, Isabella, that's all I ever hear."

  "So why did you even suggest this if you felt that way?"

  "Because I thought if I saw you two together like that it would make it easier to live with, I thought you'd fuck her like she was nothing special and then I could rest easy knowing that you got whatever your fascination for her is out of your system, but instead you proved me right. You didn't just fuck her, you made love to her, you gave her something that was supposed to be mine."

  "What the hell do you want from me, this is crazy, did you really expect that I could turn off my caring for her and get my rocks off, is that the kind of guy you think I am?"

  "You're not getting it Drake, people have these things all the time, usually from what I've read, the partners are supposed to be in it for each other with the third-party just there for added stimulation or something, but that's not what happened on that bed, it was more like you two were lovers and I was the outsider.

  Fuck, how long had Isabella been in the tub?

  I checked my watch and that just seemed to ratchet her temper up another notch. What a fucking mess.

  "Maddy please don't do this right now okay, let's cool down before we do something rash, now I have to go check on her make sure she's okay. Our parents will be home soon, let's just please try to deal with this rationally okay."

  "Fine, but you don't touch her again, no more being all nice and cozy with her and I hope you know this was a one time thing."

  "Okay, whatever you say." I would've agreed to anything to get her to calm down.

  I needed time to think, to get my head on straight and deal with this new development.

  Chapter 7

  In the bathroom I lifted Isabella out of the water, releasing the plug so it would drain. I folded her into one of my fluffy bath sheets rubbing her skin dry.